America's #1 Mincemeat Brand | Since 1885

0
None Such Prize Cookies Mincemeat Nonsuch Recipe

Mincemeat Prize Cookies

These delicious mincemeat cookies are made with butter, sugar, eggs, and None Such® mincemeat. Easy, soft, and perfect for the holidays!
4.90 from 101 votes
Print Pin Rate
Course: Dessert
Cuisine: American
Prep Time: 15 minutes
Cook Time: 10 minutes
Servings: 60

Ingredients
 

  • 1 cup shortening or butter
  • 1.5 cups sugar
  • 3 eggs
  • 3 cups all-purpose flour
  • 1 teaspoon baking soda
  • ½ teaspoon salt
  • ½ 27 oz. jar None Such® Ready-to-Use Mincemeat ((Classic Original or Brandy and Rum))

Instructions

  • PREHEAT oven to 375°F
  • In a large mixer bowl, beat shortening and sugar until fluffy. Add eggs; beat well.
  • COMBINE dry ingredients; gradually add to shortening mixture. Mix well.
  • STIR in mincemeat.
  • DROP by rounded teaspoonfuls, 2 inches apart, onto greased baking sheets.
  • BAKE 8 to 10 minutes or until lightly browned. Cool. Makes about 6½ dozen.

Notes

Tip: For a more chewy cookie, substitute 1 (9-ounce) package None Such® Condensed Mincemeat for Ready-to-Use Mincemeat.
4.90 from 101 votes

Rate & Review

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Rating




  1. 5 stars
    These were my grandmother’s cookies she made for every holiday and I used to make them until they discontinued the condensed version of mincemeat. The cookies don’t taste the same with the jarred version.

  2. 5 stars
    Used this recipe for literally decades.. throw in a cup or more of lightly chopped walnuts and this cookie is our family’s favorite…

  3. 5 stars
    Been making these for my dad since I was a child. I bake them and send them in the mail for him to NC. I’m 58 now. The sweetest memories and the cookies are delicious.

  4. 5 stars
    I grew up eating these…only at Christmas time would my mother make them. I am 70 and she has been gone for several years. I want to continue the tradation… My question is…can you add nuts like pecans or walnuts to these?

  5. 5 stars
    I make these every Christmas. This is a cookie that my Mom made us growing up. Of she used the condensed version. I like them either way, it is one of my favorite cookies!

  6. 4 stars
    My mother made these for so many years. You want a moist chocolate chip cookie this is the best receipe ever! A favorite for Thanksgiving and Christmas.

  7. 5 stars
    I have been credited with an amazing cookie and the surprise has always been the cookies made with the non-such condensed product. Unable to receive the product for my usual cookie, friends and relatives will have to settle with Pumpkin Bread. Big disappointment

  8. 5 stars
    I dehydrated the jar of mincemeat on my multi function air fryer. Very close to the boxed mincemeat . Much more like “the old recipe”.

  9. 5 stars
    I agree condensed is best but as they don’t make it anymore, I spread the jar mincemeat on a cookie sheet lined with parchment paper and dry it in a 250 degree oven for an hour. Not exactly the same as condensed but much better than straight from the jar:)

  10. 5 stars
    My family and I’ve loved the Prize Cookies for years and so dissapointed because I can’t find the boxes anywhere. My older sister had some in oven one year I bisiofrom
    Out of town & the out was lit up with the baking cookies and she had to get me out of her kitchen and that was the first time I had them and been cooking them every since and that was early 80’s. I can’t wait for them to be on store shelves again we love them❤️❤️❤️

  11. 5 stars
    On rereading this recipe, this does not feature the Mincemeat. The recipe from the early 70s was similar dough, but the dough was flattened with raised edges like a shallow crater, the mincemeat was spooned on top in the center and topped with half a Marachino cherry. This features the mincemeat. The trick was to freeze the mini-pie cookies and eat right out of the freezer, this made the mincemeat pop. You should try this variant and publish it. The cookies were normal size but with the mincemeat featured on top and not mixed with the dough. Eat Frozen. They also look 100 times better than the cookies pictured here.

  12. 5 stars
    I can’t wait for the condensed mincemeat to come back! They are my favorite cookie. I was hoping to introduce another generation to my mothers amazing cookies.

    There is no substitute for the condensed version. I hope they bring it back soon. It’s almost time to start baking!

  13. 5 stars
    Yes I too felt they were cake like. Added a bit more flour. Still felt they tasted flat. Added chocolate chips and that did the trick. Oh so much better.

  14. 5 stars
    These cookies are better with condensed mince meat. The jar make them to cakey. I’m 69 yrs my mother use to make these when I was a little girl. They are not your prize winning cookies anymore. The ones who like the jar never had the condensed.

    1. 5 stars
      I agree with you 1000%! Bring back the condensed mincemeat!! The prize cookie recipe was our family favorite Christmas cookie for 50+ years…so sad the condensed mincemeat is not available 🙁

    2. 5 stars
      Yes! I absolutely agree, the condensed made the cookies so much better, my Mom always made them, now I do, but can’t find the condensed anymore, wish they would make it again.

    3. 5 stars
      You are so right. The mincemeat in the jar although pretty good, cannot hold a candle to the condensed mincemeat I’ve also used for many years during the holiday season for prize cookies.

    4. 5 stars
      I totally agree with you. My mother also made the cookies with the condensed. I’ve tried the jar one. Not the same at all. Cookie recipe use to be on the back of the box.

      1. 5 stars
        Our favorite cookie! Help I love them with the condensed box but now that it’s not available, I’m going to be forced to use the jar. Any suggestions? Or should I just skip making the cookie? My family has been wanting it so bad.

    5. 4 stars
      Absolutely!! The old family recipe I have used 1/2 cup water in the condensed mincemeat, and 1 egg (vs 3 that they recommend now) 1 cup shortening, 1 1/2 c sugar, 3 1/4 c SIFTED flour, 1/2 top salt and 1 tsp soda. The best, moist chewy cookies ever!

    6. 4 stars
      I agree. My grandmother always made these and they were a family favorite. I’ve been watching for the condensed version to come back because I’d love to surprise my elderly mom with an old favorite.

    7. 5 stars
      Haven’t tried making the cookies with jarred prepared mincemeat, grew up making and eating the cookies made from condensed dehydrated mincemeat. None such! Why are you always out of the condensed boxed version we love?!

  15. 5 stars
    Absolutely love these cookies, fam I ly favorite with all!! My grannie used Nonesuch for over 70 years!!! They have always been terrifuc!! Childhood memory.

    1. 5 stars
      I’ve never done that, but I bake them ahead, layer between parchment paper in plastic containers and freeze for later. They’re great right out of the freezer, just a firmer bite, but will also thaw out in a few minutes.

  16. 5 stars
    I use this mince meat for my chocolate chip mincemeat cookies. They are the BEST cookies for holidays or anytime.

  17. 5 stars
    I love these made with the Moncemeat! I wanted to enter them in a contest that is coming up in May and am so disappointed that the condensed won’t be available until next fall.

  18. 5 stars
    They are just the best holiday cookie ever. My nana used to make them for me and now I want to make them for my grandchildren. I can’t wait until you have the condensed version ready to see again!

  19. 5 stars
    It’s been a tradition in our family to make these cookies for the holidays. We love the condensed version. I will try with traditional. We are praying the condensed is available again soon. We were devastated when production stopped.

  20. 5 stars
    Not quite the recipe that I use as mine calls for full jar of mincemeat. These have been a favorite of my family for years.

  21. 5 stars
    I grew up eating these cookies and they are a Christmas tradition in my home. I do prefer the version with the condensed mincemeat, so I’m hoping you will the condensed mincemeat back. 🙂

  22. 5 stars
    This is like the Strativarious Violin of the cookies because even scientists cannot simply figure out how, despite so many YEARS, how to MAKE some more Strativarious-sounding violins even though they are worth over a MILLION DOLLARS apiece, so some saint musta prayed to Jesus to invent this recipe!!!! Use the condensed!

  23. 5 stars
    This cookie BLOWS MY MIND, praise Jesus! And I’m not even a mincemeat PIE fan, but wowee!!!! These cookies JAM!!! Woo!!

  24. 5 stars
    i remember Non Such since i was a little boy my mother made cookies and pies with it i loved bothe i still do i.I make a pie with it every Christmas
    it seems to be the only time i can find it .i am almost 90 now and still love that taste

  25. 5 stars
    I can’t wait to do the cookie. I’ve also tried a London based brand, that looks different, tastes tartly okay. But nothing beats the Nonesuch Brand.

  26. 4 stars
    If you have never had mincemeat cookies made from None Such condensed mince meat, then this recipe with Ready to use would be pretty good.

  27. 5 stars
    These cookies have been a family tradition for as long as I can remember. My grandmother made them with the dried mincemeat and they are our family’s favorite. These cookies are so special that we made them for my mother’s funeral. They were her favorite cookies and she always had several boxes of the dried mincemeat in her freezer so she could make them all year round.

  28. 5 stars
    We have eaten these cookies since I was a kid. That is over seventy years. My children, grand children, and great grand children all eat them.

  29. 5 stars
    I’m turning 70 in a few weeks. I would love to be able to buy factory direct if that’s a possibility. I would buy several cases at a time. It would be worth it to keep from having to describe the product to every stock person in every grocery store and them not knowing what I’m talking about. And yes, I agree that the other brands I’ve tried weren’t very good. I’m Jonesing for my Prize cookies.

  30. 5 stars
    I was almost heartbroken if I couldn’t make these cookies this year. Thank you for continuing to make this mincemeat. It has been a family tradition for over 50 years

  31. 5 stars
    Growing up my mother always made mincemeat pie for Thanksgiving and Christmas. When I married I continued the tradition, when I had children I discovered the cookie recipe when they were young and started making the cookies. I am now 75 and my children are 49 and 54. Last week my oldest called me on the phone and while talking he told me for the last couple weeks he has had a craving for my mincemeat cookies. I have to make him some cookies!! When I went to the store for the mincemeat I couldn’t find it! I was told the store no longer carried it, the younger generation no longer buys it!! Talk about shocked! I have only found one store in town that sells it. Please don’t stop making it, maybe we of the “older generation” can start a new trend for using mincemeat again. If my kids are starting to ask for it again maybe others will also. Thank you for being there for us that still want it.

    1. 5 stars
      Lost my mom’s mincemeat cookie recipe. So happy to find this one as it’s just like my mom’s. I also add a bit of cinnamon and nutmeg to the recipe.

  32. 4 stars
    For the past few years I have the the cookies with the jar mincemeat, although traditional I used the condensed. When using the jar mincemeat, more flour is needed to make sure they don’t spread out as much. I usually double the recipe, so I add about a 1/2 cup more flour. Ideally, the cookies should be rounded, not flat. Can’t wait till the bring back the condensed mincemeat. It makes a chewier and better tasting cookie.

  33. 5 stars
    love these cookies! I usually by my mincemeat in jar at the end of Chrisrtmas season. Walmart will put them half price. WATCH THE STORES ATER Christmas

  34. 5 stars
    So thankful Nonesuch mincemeat is back on the market !!! My mother made these cookies for years !! Now I’m carrying on the tradition year round !!

  35. 5 stars
    I have made these cookies all my adult life. I add a bit of grand manier liquor and frost with a butter cream frosting made with FRESH orange juice I also add a cup of toasted walnuts. I use Irish butter

  36. 5 stars
    This recipe is the one my mother used for years and now I do. I am incredibly disappointed to not be able to find any more condensed mincemeat and that is all she ever used. This will be my first year using the jar, wish me luck!

  37. 5 stars
    We are so happy to have None Such mincemeat back!!!! Mincemeat cookies are our absolute favorite cookie!!!! I’m 70 and have had these cookies since I was a kid. Always my favorite. Tried another brand when I couldn’t get None Such and it was awful.

  38. 5 stars
    Are you using butter for the shortening or something like Crisco? I have been making British style mince pies for years but they are messy so want to try these.

    1. 5 stars
      I use unsalted butter, better tasting than shortening. Make sure your butter is at room temperature. The jar mincemeat makes a cakier cookie as compared to the condensed mincemeat.

  39. 5 stars
    I have looked all over for the BOX of mince meat… I have baked the cookies for many years. Please where scan I find it… My family would be forever greatfull … They are one of the best.

  40. 5 stars
    Started baking these when I was 10, 50 yrs ago, & my Dad’s favorite cookie (his Mom immigrated from the UK). Look forward to it becoming available again.

  41. 5 stars
    Ditto. For me as well. I am 69. My mom only made this cookie at Thankgiving and Chridtmas. It was a special treat. I do not like the ready-to-use because it it not what my Mama used. So, I order the NoneSuch Condensed Mincemeat online.

  42. 5 stars
    Can’t find the mincemeat in the small box, is it not available. If I use the mincemeat in the jar would the cookies be the same.

  43. 5 stars
    I too have been enjoying these fabulous cookies my whole life (69 years). Unfortunately, I live in the Upper Peninsula of Michigan and NOT ONE grocery store in the entire UP carries None Such (or any other brand, for that matter) Mincemeat!!!!! So, no more mincemeat cookies for me………..sad, sad, sad………

    1. 5 stars
      Hello Jennifer,
      You can find the NoneSuch jar mincemeat at Amazon BUT it is $$$ more than it should be. However I bit the bullet and got two. Then an informative email direct from NoneSuch gave me a list of some stores that have it (none of them are in my area … northern CA). Sign up with the company to keep you posted on when more stores will have it. I imagine that the Company is working overtime to get product on store shelves. Hope this was helpful for you.

  44. 5 stars
    Mom made these when I was a child and I continued for my grown children and grandchildren. Best recipe ever!

  45. 5 stars
    I have been eating these mincemeat cookies my whole life (70 years) and absolutely love them. They are my favorite!!

  46. 2 stars
    Best with the concentrate as the jar cannot match flavor or consistency. I gave 5 stars based on the concentrate and would only give it a 2 with the jar

    1. 5 stars
      This has been a family tradition in my home for as long as I can remember and I’m 62 years old. My grandmother and my mother as well as myself and my sister always have baked this recipe for the holidays, but we have always used the condensed mincemeat. I’m so disappointed that I’m unable to find it anymore but I will try the recipe with the ready to use jarred mincemeat and see how it turns out. Not ready to give up baking mincemeat cookies yet.

More Suggested Recipes

GET AN

IN-STOCK ALERT

None Such Mince Meat Newsletter

Searching for
None Such® Mincemeat?

Searching for None Such®?

Get notified when it’s in-stock again this year – online or at your local store!

0